| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Emily Blunt | Lady Cornelia Locke | 6 |
| Chaske Spencer | Eli Whipp | 6 |
| Tom Hughes | Thomas Trafford | 5 |
| Steve Wall | Thin Kelly | 5 |
| Stephen Rea | Sheriff Robert Marshall | 4 |
| Nicholas Aaron | Billy Myers | 3 |
| William Belleau | Kills on Water | 3 |
| Cristian Solimeno | Clay Jackson | 3 |
| Valerie Pachner | Martha Myers | 3 |
| Walt Klink | Jed Myers | 3 |
| Sam Alexander | Trooper Scott | 2 |
| Rafe Spall | David Melmont | 2 |
| Tonantzin Carmelo | Touching Ground | 2 |
| Gary Farmer | John Clarke | 2 |
| Julian Bleach | Jerome McClintock | 2 |
| Ben Temple | Dutch Van de Lote | 2 |
| Tadhg Murphy | Tap O'Neil | 2 |
| Kimberly Guerrero | Katie Clarke | 2 |
| Rod Rondeaux | Trooper Charlie White | 2 |
| Ciarán Hinds | Richard M Watts | 1 |
| Toby Jones | Sebold Cusk | 1 |
| Sule Rimi | Captain Knox | 1 |
| Ian Pirie | Keir Grant | 1 |
| Forrest Goodluck | White Moon | 1 |
| Jack Klaff | Flathead Jackson | 1 |
| Nathan Osgood | E.J. Jenson | 1 |
| Sheldon Peters Wolfchild | Red Elk | 1 |
| Cokey Falkow | Lead Horseman | 1 |
| Jon Bermúdez | Drew | 1 |