| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Neil Flynn | Fred | 10 |
| Natalie Morales | Abby | 10 |
| Nelson Franklin | Bill | 10 |
| Kimia Behpoornia | Rosie | 10 |
| Leonard Ouzts | James | 10 |
| Patrick Gorman | Skip | 7 |
| Will Greenberg | Dan | 3 |
| Tracie Thoms | Emily | 1 |
| Rob Huebel | Clark | 1 |
| Bob Glouberman | Dale | 1 |
| Mary Holland | Sharon | 1 |
| Sam Pancake | Richard | 1 |
| Concetta Tomei | Nemo | 1 |
| Jack Wallace | Skip | 1 |
| Carmine Caridi | Kip | 1 |
| Lynette DuPree | Angie | 1 |
| John Deignan | Teddy | 1 |
| Andre Boyer | Random Guy | 1 |
| Rasika Mathur | Customer | 1 |
| Buddy Sosthand | Cop | 1 |