| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Jon Bernthal | Michael H. Sussman | 6 |
| Oscar Isaac | Nick Wasicsko | 6 |
| Winona Ryder | Vinni Restiano | 6 |
| Alfred Molina | Henry J. Spallone | 6 |
| Catherine Keener | Mary Dorman | 6 |
| Jim Belushi | Angelo Martinelli | 6 |
| Terry Kinney | Peter Smith | 6 |
| Peter Riegert | Oscar Newman | 6 |
| Bob Balaban | Leonard B. Sand | 6 |
| Dominique Fishback | Billie Rowan | 6 |
| LaTanya Richardson Jackson | Norma O'Neal | 6 |
| Ilfenesh Hadera | Carmen Febles | 6 |
| McKinley Belcher III | Dwayne Meeks | 6 |
| Michael Stahl-David | Jim Surdoval | 6 |
| Saverio Guerra | Neil DeLuca | 6 |
| Natalie Paul | Doreen Henderson | 6 |
| Jeff Lima | John Santos, Jr. | 6 |
| Carla Quevedo | Nay Noe Wasicsko | 6 |
| Kyanna Simone Simpson | Tasha O'Neal | 4 |
| Josh Salatin | Michael Wasicsko | 3 |
| Clarke Peters | Robert Mayhawk | 2 |
| Daniel Sauli | Terry Zaleski | 2 |
| Remy Auberjonois | Michael Sculnick | 2 |
| Bruce Altman | Buddy Dorman | 1 |
| Luke Kirby | Edwin E. McAmis | 1 |
| Michael Kostroff | Ralph Arred | 1 |
| Jordan Bridges | Times Reporter | 1 |
| Patrick Breen | Paul W. Pickelle | 1 |
| Daniel O'Shea | Witness | 1 |
| J. Mallory McCree | Skip | 1 |
| Gary Littman | Dave Sheingold | 1 |
| Craig DiFrancia | Yonkers Police officer | 1 |