| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Julia Stiles | Blue | 42 |
| Uriah Shelton | Josh | 24 |
| Kathleen Quinlan | Jessica | 7 |
| Carla Gallo | Rose | 5 |
| James Morrison | Olsen | 5 |
| Eric Stoltz | Arthur | 4 |
| Jacob Vargas | Roy | 4 |
| Jane Stiles | Lara | 4 |
| Brian Shortall | Will | 4 |
| David Harbour | Cooper | 3 |
| Amir Arison | Leonard | 3 |
| Sarah Paulson | Lavinia | 2 |
| Taylor Nichols | Bill | 2 |
| Rocky Carroll | Robert | 2 |
| Laura Spencer | Vanessa | 2 |
| Chad Lindberg | Sam | 2 |
| Michael Hyatt | Claire | 2 |
| Joel McKinnon Miller | Mr. Weston | 2 |
| Daren Kagasoff | Daren | 2 |
| Jeanne Tripplehorn | Vera | 1 |
| Michelle Forbes | Marisa | 1 |
| William Petersen | Mitch | 1 |
| James Jordan | Raphael | 1 |
| Mark Consuelos | Daniel | 1 |
| Tony Plana | Stribling | 1 |
| Samantha Quan | Dana | 1 |
| Wanda De Jesus | Cynthia | 1 |
| Holly Robinson Peete | Holly | 1 |
| J.R. Cacia | Male Client | 1 |
| Mark Rhino Smith | Rupert | 1 |
| I. Elijah Baughman | Man Talking | 1 |
| JC Gonzalez | Harry | 1 |
| Debi Manwiller | Waitress | 1 |
| Darin Heames | Nicolas | 1 |