| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Dakota Johnson | Kate Fox | 13 |
| Lucy Punch | BJ 'Beatrice Joan' Harrison | 13 |
| Alan Ruck | Principal Geoff Feeney | 13 |
| Nat Faxon | Ben Fox | 13 |
| Maggie Elizabeth Jones | Maddie Fox | 13 |
| Echo Kellum | Tommy | 13 |
| Brittany Snow | Lila | 4 |
| Melinda McGraw | Vera Everson | 3 |
| Rob Corddry | Buddy | 2 |
| Rosa Salazar | Molly | 1 |
| Bruce McGill | Randy Fox | 1 |
| Niecy Nash-Betts | Roz | 1 |
| Dave Annable | Greg | 1 |
| Jennette McCurdy | Bethany | 1 |
| Leslie Grossman | Nan | 1 |
| Jesse McCartney | Jesse | 1 |
| Vernee Watson-Johnson | Gladys | 1 |
| Amber Stevens West | Anna Lewis | 1 |
| Mary Birdsong | Deanne | 1 |
| Tony Cavalero | Donovan | 1 |
| Jane Seymour | Wendy | 1 |
| Christopher Cousins | Dave | 1 |
| Judy Kain | Interviewer | 1 |
| Tim Bagley | Mr. Caruthers | 1 |
| Geoff Stults | Will | 1 |
| George Alan | Jeremy | 1 |
| Loretta Fox | Helen | 1 |
| Laird Macintosh | Roger | 1 |
| Ayumi Iizuka | Receptionist | 1 |