| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| McKenzie Westmore | Self - Host | 162 |
| Neville Page | Self - Judge | 162 |
| Michael Westmore | Self - Mentor | 162 |
| Rick Baker | Guest Judge | 2 |
| Elizabeth Mitchell | Guest Judge | 1 |
| Doug Jones | Guest Judge | 1 |
| John Rhys-Davies | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
| Cheyenne Jackson | Guest Judge | 1 |
| Neil Druckmann | Guest Judge | 1 |
| Paul W. S. Anderson | Guest Judge | 1 |
| John Wynn | Self | 1 |
| Cassandra Peterson | Elvira | 1 |
| John Landis | Guest Judge | 1 |
| Oren Peli | Self | 1 |
| Jim Lee | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
| Marcus Nispel | Guest Judge | 1 |
| Lois Burwell | Guest Judge | 1 |
| Todd Masters | Himself | 1 |
| Dan Didio | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |