| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Adrian Chiles | Self - Presenter | 186 |
| Adrian Chiles | Host | 149 |
| Colin Murray | Self - Presenter | 97 |
| Colin Murray | Host | 89 |
| Jermaine Jenas | Pundit | 69 |
| Alan Shearer | Pundit | 67 |
| Jermaine Jenas | Self | 35 |
| Ian Wright | Pundit | 30 |
| Alan Hansen | Pundit | 22 |
| Gabby Logan | Host | 11 |
| Ruud Gullit | Pundit | 10 |
| Alex Scott | Pundit | 6 |
| Peter Crouch | Pundit | 6 |
| Gary Lineker | Host | 5 |
| Alan Shearer | Self - Pundit | 3 |
| Jermaine Jenas | Self - Pundit | 3 |
| Scott Mills | Self | 1 |
| Noel Gallagher | Pundit | 1 |
| Frank Lampard | Self - Interviewee | 1 |
| Alex Scott | Self - Presenter | 1 |
| Pep Guardiola | Self - Interviewee | 1 |
| Harry Redknapp | Pundit | 1 |
| Jürgen Klopp | Self - Interviewee | 1 |
| Ian Wright | Self - Pundit | 1 |