| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Matt Polinsky | Corey Graves | 52 |
| Manuel Alfonso Andrade Oropeza | Andrade | 6 |
| Muñoz González | Dragon Lee | 5 |
| Candice LeRae | Candice LeRae | 5 |
| Nattie Neidhart-Wilson | Natalya | 4 |
| Peter England | Pete Dunne | 4 |
| Kayleigh Rae | Alba Fyre | 4 |
| Theresa Serrano | Zoey Stark | 3 |
| Josh Harter | Chris Sabin | 3 |
| Austin Watson | Xavier Woods | 3 |
| Jermaine Haley | Bronson Reed | 3 |
| Akira Tozawa | Akira Tozawa | 3 |
| Tyler Bate | Tyler Bate | 3 |
| Trinity Fatu | Naomi | 2 |
| Sesugh Uhaa | Apollo Crews | 2 |
| Tommaso Whitney | Tommaso Ciampa | 2 |
| Thomas Pestock | Baron Corbin | 2 |
| Todd Smith | Ivar | 2 |
| Kaori Housako | Kairi Sane | 2 |
| Bronson Rechsteiner | Bron Breakker | 2 |
| Jordan Devlin | JD McDonagh | 2 |
| Bryan Kelly | Byron Saxton | 2 |
| Benjamin Timms | Nathan Frazer | 2 |
| Maddie Knisley | Thea Hail | 2 |
| Marcel Barthel | Ludwig Kaiser | 1 |
| Matt Farrelly | Grayson Waller | 1 |
| Kenneth Crawford | Montez Ford | 1 |
| Chelsea Cardona | Chelsea Green | 1 |
| Aoife Cusack | Lyra Valkyria | 1 |
| Chad Allegra | Karl Anderson | 1 |
| Gary Gordon | Angelo Dawkins | 1 |
| Raúl Mendoza | Cruz del Toro | 1 |
| Dominick Gutiérrez | Dominik Mysterio | 1 |
| Christopher Dijak | Dijak | 1 |
| Ilja Rukober | Ilja Dragunov | 1 |
| Jacob Kasper | Julius Creed | 1 |
| Kimberly Benson | Piper Niven | 1 |
| Raymond Rowe | Erik | 1 |
| Austin White | Austin Theory | 1 |