| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Sarah Schneider | Sarah | 17 |
| Sam Reich | Sam | 15 |
| Streeter Seidell | Streeter | 13 |
| Josh Ruben | Josh | 9 |
| Adam Conover | Adam | 5 |
| Brian McElhaney | Brian | 2 |
| Emily Axford | Emily | 2 |
| Ben Schwartz | Branch Windwood | 1 |
| Ben Schwartz | Ben | 1 |
| Thomas Middleditch | John McClane | 1 |
| Josh Ruben | Gale Beggy | 1 |
| Josh Ruben | Phil Hoffman | 1 |
| Josh Ruben | Thug #1 | 1 |
| Josh Ruben | Hans Gruber | 1 |
| Josh Ruben | Masked Creep | 1 |
| Josh Ruben | Roger | 1 |
| Kevin Heffernan | Self | 1 |
| Zach Cregger | 1 | |
| Trevor Moore | 1 | |
| Steve Lemme | Self | 1 |
| Elaine Carroll | Elaine | 1 |
| Sam Reich | Phil Hoffman | 1 |
| Pete Holmes | Phil Hoffman | 1 |
| Pete Holmes | Desmond | 1 |
| Jon Gabrus | Leroy the Women's Bathroom Attendant | 1 |
| Jon Gabrus | Gabrus | 1 |
| Jon Gabrus | Flügson | 1 |
| Jon Gabrus | Master Torturer | 1 |
| Jon Gabrus | Self | 1 |
| Emily Axford | Self | 1 |
| Chris Gethard | Chris | 1 |
| Chris Gethard | Hugh Jackman | 1 |
| Chris Gethard | The Internet | 1 |
| Mike Trapp | Sandman | 1 |
| Sarah Schneider | Sarah / Bizarro Sarah | 1 |
| Sarah Schneider | Sarah / Douche Sarah | 1 |
| Sarah Schneider | Melissa | 1 |
| Streeter Seidell | Self | 1 |
| Streeter Seidell | Streeter / Bizarro Streeter | 1 |
| Streeter Seidell | Phantom | 1 |
| Streeter Seidell | Torturer #2 | 1 |
| Streeter Seidell | Streeter / Douche Streeter | 1 |
| Sam Brown | 1 |