| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Jeff Morrow | 78 | |
| Douglass Dumbrille | 78 | |
| Vincent Price | 1 | |
| Vincent Price | Rev. Robert Russell | 1 |
| Lloyd Corrigan | David Selden | 1 |
| Robert Warwick | Chief Justice | 1 |
| James Dean | Man in Crowd | 1 |
| Sue George | Sheila | 1 |
| Strother Martin | Landry Kersh | 1 |
| Paul Kelly | Fr. Bill Rigge | 1 |
| Jonathan Hale | Governor | 1 |
| Dayton Lummis | Prosecutor | 1 |
| Wheaton Chambers | R.W. Bergen | 1 |
| Paul Birch | Chief Crane | 1 |
| Jack Perrin | Associate Justice | 1 |
| Sally Blane | Mrs. Russell | 1 |
| Brian Aherne | 1 | |
| James Whitmore | 1 | |
| Gregory Gaye | 1 | |
| Charles Halton | Judge | 1 |
| Joan Vohs | 1 | |
| Howard Petrie | Matt Ridge | 1 |
| John Archer | Ramsey Carr | 1 |
| Frank Marlowe | (uncredited) | 1 |
| Raymond Greenleaf | Gibson Collier | 1 |
| Adam Kennedy | 1 | |
| Peter J. Votrian | George Gilgo | 1 |
| G. Pat Collins | (uncredited) | 1 |
| James Kirkwood | Justice Deal | 1 |
| Nolan Leary | Jury Foreman | 1 |