| Broken Arrow is a Western series which ran on ABC-TV in prime time from 1956 through 1958 on Tuesdays at 9 p.m. Eastern time. Repeat episodes were shown by ABC on Sunday afternoons during the 1959–60 season. Selected repeats were then shown once again in prime time during the summer of 1960. |
| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Michael Ansara | Cochise | 71 |
| John Lupton | 71 | |
| Tom Fadden | 71 | |
| Steven Ritch | Nakaya | 3 |
| William Challee | Sergeant (uncredited) | 2 |
| Zon Murray | Lemmer | 1 |
| Fred Graham | Sergeant | 1 |
| Fred Graham | Sgt. Dobbs | 1 |
| Fred Graham | Thug (uncredited) | 1 |
| Angie Dickinson | Terry Weaver | 1 |
| Paul Fix | Jess Taugus | 1 |
| Tom London | (uncredited) | 1 |
| Leo Gordon | Will Carr | 1 |
| Paul E. Burns | Hotel Clerk | 1 |
| Henry Brandon | Judd Buckley | 1 |
| John Doucette | Bobo Conway | 1 |
| John Doucette | Cagle | 1 |
| Strother Martin | Renton | 1 |
| Frank Puglia | Judson | 1 |
| Ted de Corsia | Ben Cartwright | 1 |
| Ted de Corsia | Cartwright | 1 |
| Robert Blake | Young Apache Warrior (uncredited) | 1 |
| Robert Blake | Machogee | 1 |
| Robert Blake | Viklai | 1 |
| John Harmon | Cal Bentley | 1 |
| John Harmon | Sam Sweeney | 1 |
| Denver Pyle | Fred Graf | 1 |
| Leonard Nimoy | Winnoa | 1 |
| George J. Lewis | Chief Kotoy | 1 |
| Paul Picerni | Maj. Gregory Markson | 1 |
| Kathryn Card | Abigail Adams | 1 |
| Tom Fadden | Milt Duffield | 1 |
| Alvy Moore | Daniels | 1 |
| Frank Wilcox | Colonel Cordell | 1 |
| Gilman Rankin | Okala | 1 |
| Harry Harvey | Judge | 1 |
| Harry Harvey | Judge Willis | 1 |
| Harry Harvey | Len Everetts | 1 |
| Edward Earle | Secretary of Interior | 1 |
| Percy Helton | Stage Passenger (uncredited) | 1 |
| Percy Helton | Higgens | 1 |
| George Cisar | Bud Holmes | 1 |
| Cyril Delevanti | Stage Passenger | 1 |
| Dick Wessel | Bartender | 1 |
| Eugene Iglesias | Tahzay | 1 |
| Eugene Iglesias | Cheewaukee | 1 |
| Damian O'Flynn | Chester Hawkins | 1 |
| John Pickard | Sergeant | 1 |
| Sam Flint | Phil | 1 |
| Sam Flint | Sheriff | 1 |
| Robert Cabal | Tahzay | 1 |
| Chuck Courtney | Young Private | 1 |
| Charles Seel | Oly | 1 |
| Larry J. Blake | Dominick | 1 |
| Howard Petrie | Sam Carson | 1 |
| Terry Frost | Bledsoe | 1 |
| Dan Riss | Roger Wetherly | 1 |
| Guy Wilkerson | Stagecoach Driver | 1 |
| Tris Coffin | Deputy Commissioner | 1 |
| Steven Ritch | Nukaya | 1 |
| Steven Ritch | First Apache | 1 |
| Victor Sen Yung | Ling Tang | 1 |
| Dick Rich | Sgt. Callahan | 1 |
| Rachel Ames | Terry Wilson | 1 |
| Rory Mallinson | (uncredited) | 1 |
| Gloria Henry | Sister Teresa | 1 |
| Phil Tead | Amos | 1 |
| Stuart Randall | U.S. Marshal | 1 |
| Paul Smith | Young Man | 1 |
| Florenz Ames | Emperor Joshua Norton | 1 |
| Lyle Talbot | Judge Judd Hinshaw | 1 |
| Robert Armstrong | Inspector Higgins | 1 |
| James Dobson | Tim Conway | 1 |
| Robert "Buzz" Henry | Rano | 1 |
| George Pembroke | Wade Nichols | 1 |
| George Chandler | Welsh | 1 |