| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Jessica Hynes | Old Myers | 6 |
| Daniel Rigby | Hebble | 6 |
| Tim Key | Gideon Bannister | 6 |
| Daisy May Cooper | Thomasine Gooch | 6 |
| Tuwaine Barrett | Cumberlidge | 5 |
| Dan Renton Skinner | Beekeeper | 2 |
| Vincent Franklin | Topcliffe | 2 |
| Joplin Sibtain | John Stearne | 2 |
| Rosie Cavaliero | Mrs. Jennings | 2 |
| Michelle Greenidge | Landlady | 2 |
| Dan Mersh | Minister Jennings | 2 |
| Ricky Tomlinson | Crockett | 1 |
| Reece Shearsmith | Matthew Hopkins | 1 |
| Julian Barratt | Fake Hopkins | 1 |
| Justin Edwards | Will Gooch | 1 |
| Angus Wright | Mr. Harvey | 1 |
| Ellie White | Karen | 1 |
| Michael Culkin | Puppeteer | 1 |
| Michael Culkin | Lord Salisbury | 1 |
| Katy Wix | Martha Pleased | 1 |
| Anil Goutam | Sophie's Dad | 1 |
| John Hollingworth | Rafe | 1 |
| Phoebe Walsh | Goodwife Seldom | 1 |
| Kiell Smith-Bynoe | Mr Griffin | 1 |
| Karl Theobald | Fake Stearne | 1 |
| Cariad Lloyd | Dorothy | 1 |
| Mike Wozniak | Hat Seller | 1 |
| Bamshad Abedi-Amin | Guard Christopher | 1 |
| Sammy Kamara | Bob | 1 |
| Seb Cardinal | Henry | 1 |
| John Arthur | Puritan Minister | 1 |
| Celeste Dring | Goodwife Griffin | 1 |
| Rachel Stubbings | Edwin's Mother | 1 |