| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Alison Pill | Betty Wendell | 10 |
| Deborah Ayorinde | Lucky Emory | 10 |
| Ryan Kwanten | George Bell | 10 |
| Shahadi Wright Joseph | Ruby Emory | 10 |
| Pam Grier | Athena | 8 |
| Jeremy Bobb | Detective Ronald McKinney | 8 |
| Deborah Ayorinde | Detective Dawn Reeve | 8 |
| Luke James | Edmund Gaines | 8 |
| Joshua J. Williams | Kel Reeve | 8 |
| Christopher Heyerdahl | The Black Hat Man | 7 |
| Jeremiah Birkett | Da Tap Dance Man | 7 |
| Carlito Olivero | Detective Joaquin Diaz | 7 |
| Liam McIntyre | Clarke Wendell | 6 |
| Wayne Knight | Lieutenant Schiff | 5 |
| Pat Healy | Marty Dixon | 5 |
| John Patrick Jordan | Earl Denton | 5 |
| Sophie Guest | Doris | 5 |
| Derek Phillips | Sergeant Bull Wheatley | 4 |
| Kim Shaw | Carol Lynn Denton | 4 |
| Abbie Cobb | Nat Dixon | 4 |
| Brooke Smith | Helen Koistra | 3 |
| Anika Noni Rose | Ella Mae Johnson | 3 |
| Paula Jai Parker | Hazel Emory | 3 |
| P.J. Byrne | Stuart Berks | 3 |
| Bailey Noble | Marlene | 3 |
| Malcolm M. Mays | Calvin | 3 |
| Cuyle Carvin | Buzz Cut | 3 |
| Charles Brice | Reggie Marks | 3 |
| Dale Dickey | The Woman | 2 |
| Lindsey Kraft | Midge Pruitt | 2 |
| Shane Johnson | Investigator Phillips | 2 |
| Kate McNeil | Dr. Frances Moynihan | 2 |
| Tim Russ | The Custodian | 2 |
| Darin Cooper | Detective Marsh | 2 |
| Susan Wood | Stella | 2 |
| Brandon O'Dell | Rio | 2 |
| Steven Sean Garland | Detective Simms | 2 |
| Maurice J. Irvin | Roland Johnson | 2 |
| Zakary Risinger | Tommy | 2 |
| Ryan Kennedy | Gary | 2 |
| Burl Moseley | Emmett | 1 |
| Barry Livingston | Real Estate Commissioner | 1 |
| Summer H. Howell | Elder Cora | 1 |
| Michael Harney | Otto Haber | 1 |
| Van Epperson | Banker | 1 |
| Robert Curtis Brown | Dr. Gaines | 1 |
| David Bowe | Mitch | 1 |
| Gene Silvers | Elder Luther | 1 |
| Melinda Page Hamilton | Elder Sara | 1 |
| Lisa Banes | Esther Haber | 1 |
| Peter MacKenzie | Mr. Stoat | 1 |
| J. Paul Boehmer | Elder James | 1 |
| Scott Alan Smith | Fuller | 1 |
| Sonia Jackson | Elderly Black Woman | 1 |
| Ella McKenzie Gross | So-Young | 1 |
| Shahadi Wright Joseph | Ruby Lee Emory | 1 |
| Brooke Jaye Taylor | Wendy McKinney | 1 |
| Ricky Wayne | M.E. Furrow | 1 |
| Christopher Murray | Murray | 1 |
| Stephen Louis Grush | James Stenson | 1 |
| Drew Matthews | Officer Becker | 1 |
| Deion Smith | Malcolm | 1 |
| Rebecca Lines | Adelle | 1 |
| Chris Bylsma | Bram | 1 |
| Sarah Minnich | Maud | 1 |
| Sarah Benoit | Stern Nurse | 1 |
| Miguel A. Gaetan | Grim Faced Cop | 1 |
| Paul David Story | Officer Rollins | 1 |
| Charles Ambrose | Cop #1 | 1 |
| Mitch Westphal | Cop | 1 |
| Elena Campbell-Martinez | Ernestina | 1 |
| Muretta Moss | Reporter | 1 |
| Chantal Maurice | Destiny | 1 |
| Kyrie McAlpin | Young Ruby | 1 |
| J. Mallory McCree | Junius Emory | 1 |
| Cranston Johnson | Grafton | 1 |
| Brian Ashton Smith | Officer Terrence | 1 |
| Tom Fitzpatrick | Shopkeeper | 1 |
| Rueben Grundy | Carter Beaumont | 1 |
| Penelope Young | Mackenzie | 1 |